© 2026 Western New York Public Broadcasting Association

140 Lower Terrace St.
Buffalo, NY 14202

Toronto Address:
130 Queens Quay E.
Suite 903
Toronto, ON M5A 0P6


Mailing Address:
Horizons Plaza P.O. Box 1263
Buffalo, NY 14240-1263

Buffalo Toronto Public Media | Phone 716-845-7000
BTPM NPR Newsroom | Phone: 716-845-7040
Differing shades of blue wavering throughout the image
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Appeals court ruling restores aggravating factors arguments in Gendron federal case

FILE - Payton Gendron, center, listens as he is sentenced, Feb 15, 2023, in Buffalo, N.Y.
Derek Gee
/
Pool via The Buffalo News
FILE - Payton Gendron, center, listens as he is sentenced in his state trial, Feb 15, 2023, in Buffalo, N.Y.

Federal prosecutors in Tops shooter Peyton Gendron’s upcoming trial may include three aggravating factors in their argument for the death penalty, a federal appellate court ruled Monday.

Those factors are Gendron’s racist motive behind the May 14, 2022 mass shooting, his alleged attempt to inspire other acts of violence, and the impact of the shooting on surviving victims.

Gendron was convicted in a state trial for the fatal shootings of ten Black people and the wounding of three other victims. On the day of his attack, a lengthy series of racist documents and essays were posted. It was pulled from the internet shortly after the shootings, but prosecutors are expected to argue his writings showed his racial motivation behind the shootings and his hope that his deeds would inspire additional acts of violence.

Monday’s ruling allows prosecutors to use these factors in the penalty phase of the federal trial, if it comes to that stage.
The case resumes in U.S. District Court Thursday with a status conference.

Potential jurors first received questionnaires in June. In-person jury selection is scheduled to begin August 17, while opening statements are tentatively scheduled to begin October 13.