The Erie County District Attorney’s Office says a Williamsville man has pleaded guilty to two child sexual abuse counts in State Supreme Court.
John Camardo, III, 47, admitted to one count of second degree rape and one count of second degree Course of Sexual Conduct Against a Child. Both charges are Class D felonies.
The victims, according to the criminal complaint, were under the ages of 15 and 13 years old, respectively, and the defendant was known to both of them.
According to investigators, the abuse against the older victim happened between the dates of April 1, 2024 and about May 31, 2024, while the second victim was subjected to abuse at least twice between the dates of April 1, 2025 and about June 20, 2026. The crimes happened in Amherst, according to the DA, but a specific venue was not identified.
Until recently, Camardo was serving as executive pastor at The Chapel, which operates worship centers in Getzville, Cheektowaga, Niagara Falls, and Lockport. Officials at The Chapel explained that upon learning of the case against Camardo he was placed on immediate administrative leave. Church attendees were advised of his resignation early last week. The Chapel addresses the investigation in a lengthy statement.
He also served as a girls’ coach in the Amherst Soccer Association. The organization issued a written statement on its website Monday evening: "Amherst Soccer Association (ASA) is able to confirm that Mr. Camardo has had a role as Coach and Referee with the organization and was shocked to learn today of the allegations against him and his conviction. Amherst Soccer had no involvement in the investigation that led to his conviction or knowledge of the situation facing Mr. Camardo until reading about it in the media today. Upon learning about his conviction today, Amherst Soccer acted swiftly to ensure Mr. Camardo was removed from any interaction with our soccer activities.
"Our hearts hurt for the victims, and we are pleased that law enforcement and the judicial system is holding him accountable for his actions. The association is consulting with governing league leadership to ensure all appropriate steps are taken. Ensuring the safety of all within our soccer community is our top priority, and we hold adults in our organization to the highest standards of conduct. Because this is an active legal matter, Amherst Soccer will not speculate on facts beyond what has been publicly reported, and will cooperate with the authorities as necessary."
Camardo could face six to eight years in prison when sentenced September 10. He is currently held without bail, and additionally temporary orders of protection have been issued on behalf of his victims.